College Rejection: Understanding the Tufts Syndrome

September 14, 2017

Ever heard of the term Tufts Syndrome? One of our recently graduated high school interns have and Aditya wants to share with you what it means and how it affects your application.

Getting rejected from your dream school might make you upset—it’s only expected. But getting rejected (or waitlisted) from your safety school will just make you feel frustrated and icky inside, possibly raising questions like “Did I forget to send them something?”, or forcing you to call admissions and rage about why you deserved to get in. Because, it’s called your “safety” school for a reason.

Why did you get rejected? 

Naturally, the most legitimate reason should be you weren’t qualified enough or you aren’t the right fit for the university you applied for. But, over the years, students, families and admissions experts have started to think otherwise. 

Many people often forget that college admissions is a two-way relationship. Applicants wants to be noticed by colleges, and colleges want to attract more applicants. Given the competitive application environment, most applicants are applying to at least 8-10 schools. In turn, colleges want to make sure that the applicants they accept will enroll, making the college look even more attractive. This is what we call the yield rate. 

Yield rate is a statistic that represents the percentage of students who matriculate to a given school upon admittance. This number is a very significant indicator of colleges’ reputations among high school seniors. Naturally, colleges want to maximize it.

Maximizing Yield Rate

There are several ways they can do this. Many institutions offer the early decision (ED) application process in which students are bound to attend once admitted. The only way to morally break an ED contract is if the college’s net price ends up being unaffordable to the accepted student. This is a very tactical method of improving a given college’s yield rate because virtually everyone who is admitted during the ED round will attend. It’s also why applying ED might seem “easier”, because the acceptance rate is higher since colleges want to guarantee 40-50% of their upcoming class early. 

Other methods also include offering merit scholarships to qualified applicants to attract them to go to their institution at a lower cost. 

Finally, there’s what people commonly refer to as the Tufts Syndrome. In general, applicants are accepted if there’s strong indication they would attend upon acceptance. It should seem obvious that universities want to accept qualified students who want to enroll; why else do they ask applicants to write the “Why Us” college-specific supplemental essay. But, here’s the catch: students who are highly qualified may get waitlisted or rejected from universities on the assumption that they are likely to get accepted and thus enroll at more prestigious universities.

Would a college really like to admit someone with an SAT composite score that is 700 points higher than the average for last class’s admitted students? What about someone with a GPA well beyond the college’s 75th percentile for recent admits? Well sure, as it improves their numbers, right? It really just depends on whether or not the college prioritizes yield rate over their statistics.

Applying to college?
View the app files and essays of accepted students.
LEARN MORE

What does this mean for you? 

Honestly, nothing. If you end up being victim of the alleged Tufts Syndrome, there’s virtually no way to prove that a particular college rejected you because you were overqualified, as there are numerous aspects to the college admissions process that make up the decision beyond just numbers. While it’s certainly an accomplishment to get into all the schools you applied to, that’s not all there is to the application process. Plus, you can only commit to one school anyways. 

So, while it may feel like a slight setback, focus on the schools you did get accepted to! Want to avoid this overall? Make sure you’re applying to colleges that are the best fit for you, and that you are demonstrating genuine interest in your application essays! 

About The Author

AdmitSee Staff
AdmitSee Staff

​We remember our frustration with applying to college and the lack of information surrounding it. So we created AdmitSee to bring much-needed transparency to the application process! Read more about the team here.




Browse Successful Application Files

elle2020
Brown ‘20


Accepted to Brown, UPenn, Wellesley, Kenyon, Macalester, Holyoke, Harvard, Bowdoin

Just another girl finally through the college apps rat race. I'm happy to share with you what I did to get through it! Currently I'm pre-law and possibly majoring in Public Policy.
Lia_Columbia
Columbia ‘19


Accepted to Columbia

I'm a student at Columbia. I love writing, activism, terrible jokes, and binge-watching Netflix. Aspiring English teacher.
BrownDomer
Notre Dame ‘20


Accepted to BU, Emory, Swarthmore, Notre Dame

Hello! I'm an international student from Ethiopia and I'll be majoring in Biology. I'd love to share all the tips and tricks I've learned from my rather unique college application experience with you!
VivienneEve23
UC Berkeley ‘20


Accepted to UC Berkeley, Brown, Claremont (CMC), Columbia, Cornell, Harvard, Northwestern, Pomona, Stanford, San Diego, Vanderbilt, UCSC, UCSB, UCSD, UCLA, Cal Poly, Cal Poly Pomona, Washington

Los Angeles kid attending UC Berkeley, Class of 2020! Planning on studying business or economics. Go Bears!

New Posts

College Supplemental Essays That Worked: Tips & Inspiration
College Supplemental Essays That Worked: Tips & Inspiration
November 20, 2017

As we enter the last stretch of this college application season, it’s time to switch gears and focus on the additional supplemental essays.College supplemental essays are what makes the application process so challenging....

10 College Interview Questions You Should Prepare For
10 College Interview Questions You Should Prepare For
November 17, 2017

Early applications are in and applicants should start preparing for the next application step: the college interview. About College Interviews First thing you should know about college interviews is that you probably won’t have...

Load More Posts