Insider Access: What Admissions Officers Tell Their Own Kids

April 06, 2016

When it comes to the college application process,  parents of college-bound kids have heard it all before: be emotionally supportive, give your input only if it’s requested… That’s all well and good, but what advice should you give when you do give it? How do you know you’re providing sound advice? In a recent NY Times survey, enrollment directors and deans of admission, who are also parents of high school or college students, shared the tips they would give their kids and other parents.

Be introspective. Ask: What motivates you?

Diane Anci, Kenyon College

Anci has a list of questions she plans to ask her children that will empower them to confidently say, “I’m the kind of person who…”

  • Do you like the idea of being the smartest student in your class or surrounded by really smart kids?

  • Is it important to find a specific course of study or to have a wide range of options?

  • Do you like the idea of meeting five new people a day or finding five people who will be your friends for life?

  • Are you drawn to familiar people and places or are you excited by a new region, meeting students from across the nation and around the world?

  • Do you prefer to work in a highly collaborative environment or are you energized by competition?

Submitting earlier isn’t just about time management; it’s strategic.

Clark Brigger, Penn State University

Briggers makes a deal with her kids when it comes to college applications. She tells them, “I pay for the applications completed before Labor Day, but after that, my children are responsible for the fees.” Don’t be fooled. This isn’t just to motivate them to get their applications done early. It’s a strategic move. Briggers points out, “There are thousands of applications and essays to get through. If you get yours in early, the reader may be more relaxed and in a better mood at that point in the process.”

Rejection is part of the process. How parents handle it shapes the kid’s reaction.

Doug Christiansen, Vanderbilt University

Rejection is tough for both the applicant and the parent. As the parent, you need to step up and set an example for your child. Christiansen explains, “When a rejection letter arrives, I see parents who can’t even move on because they are so mad at the school. But that is not letting the child move on. Then it is almost like the next school they get admitted to and may attend is a disappointment. Instead, tell your child: ‘It didn’t work, it is their loss, you’re wonderful, now what do we need to do to go forward?’” This may just be the emotional support your child needs from parents to help them learn how to make life decisions and manage any setbacks that may come their way.

Parents shouldn’t let their input get in the way of their love and support.

Stephen Farmer, UNC - Chapel Hill

How do you show your children you love and care during the application process? Farmer suggests giving “kids some air and room to breathe growing up”. He believes that “our kids need our love more than they need our direction about college. If that direction gets in the way of the love, it’s not helpful and it’s not worth it.” School was their education and their work - not a family project. Same goes for the college application, which is why he never read his essay when he was still applying.

Parents should take a backseat. The best students drive themselves.

Cornell B. LeSane II, Allegheny College

The applicant should be the one applying. Lesane II shares, “As an admissions officer, I’ve had parents tell me, ‘Oh, we missed a deadline — that’s my fault.’ At that point I’m thinking — just how interested is the student in our school?” How much you want to attend a school is not only indicated in your essays, but how you approach the application process. He firmly believes that students themselves should take ownership of the process, and be the drivers leading the way.

Challenge yourself, but not at the expense of spreading yourself too thin.

Stuart Schmill, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

The number of AP classes you take does not determine your self-worth, or necessarily show how smart you are. These advanced classes are there to allow high school students to challenge themselves in subjects they are interested in, and Schmill very much advocates that. He says, “You should challenge yourself. For some students this might mean taking the most advanced classes, but it also might mean taking the most advanced classes appropriate for that student, and not spreading themselves too thin.” Plus, all those APs might not even be worth it!

Figure out how your values and interests intersect with what a school offers.

Gil Villanueva, University of Richmond

Applicants are always told to have a plan, and Villanueva has one that he recommends, even to his own son! He reveals his secrets: “I’m going to hand him a spreadsheet. Across the top will be the schools, and down the side will be the list of things he feels are most important to him in a college. When he visits these schools and does his research, he’ll fill in the spreadsheet, and it will be a nice road map for him.” If you’ve been on a college tour, you’ll know that after the third, or fourth school, they all start to blend together. This helps you keep relevant notes that you can always refer back to.

Applying to college is a learning process for both the applicants and their parents, but ultimately everyone involved wants the same thing: to find the school that best fits that student. We hope these first-hand expert examples provide some perspective to help your kid make the right choice!

Browse Successful Application Files

GA Tech ‘19

Accepted to , Illinois Tech, RIT, Clarkson, Stevens, GA Tech, Case, UMich, Illinois, Colorado, Rochester

Georgia Tech Class of 2019. Studying Computer Science. Working for Google in Summer 2016
UT Austin ‘19

Accepted to UC Berkeley, USC, UMich, Illinois, UT Austin, UC Davis, UC Irvine, UCSD, UCSB, U of Minnesota, Arizona, WVU, Cal Poly, San Jose State

I'm from the SF Bay Area, but I'm betraying my roots by attending The University of Texas at Austin as a chemical engineering major. I like music, science and eating!
Stanford ‘20

Accepted to Stanford, UC Berkeley, UC Davis, UCLA

Born in small town, interested in math, science, and literature. Attending Stanford University starting fall of 2016, planning on studying engineering or computer science, with a minor in a foreign language.
Notre Dame ‘20

Accepted to BU, Emory, Swarthmore, Notre Dame

Hello! I'm an international student from Ethiopia and I'll be majoring in Biology. I'd love to share all the tips and tricks I've learned from my rather unique college application experience with you!

New Posts

Student Insight: How to Approach Transferring Colleges
Student Insight: How to Approach Transferring Colleges
January 09, 2018

Not sure if your current university is the best school for you? Consider your transfer options. No one really expects to go through the application process again after senior year in high school. But things...

How To Succeed on MCAT Test Day
How To Succeed on MCAT Test Day
January 05, 2018

Stressed out about your upcoming MCAT? Our friends at Magoosh will help you through MCAT Test Day! You’ve prepared for the MCAT for months, you’ve selected the right date for you—and it’...

Brown University Class of 2022 Results Released
Brown University Class of 2022 Results Released
December 21, 2017

Brown University admits 738 early decision applicants from the largest early admission application pool Brown has had since the early application program started 16 years ago. The 738 students who received good news from Brown make up 21.1% of...

Cornell University Welcomes 1,533 Students to the Class of 2022
Cornell University Welcomes 1,533 Students to the Class of 2022
December 20, 2017

Universities share record-breaking statistics every year when it comes to college applications and this year was no different at Cornell University. Cornell University continued to break two different records three years in a row. Earlier...

Load More Posts